Why does a bag of rice on a table not move, when gravity is pulling it down?
Your guess
Pick one before you read on. It is fine to be wrong.
By the end you can
Draw force arrows on an object and find the overall force
Explain why balanced forces do not change speed or direction
Almost nothing has only one force on it. A bag of rice on a table has two. Gravity pulls it down. The table pushes it up.
We draw a force as an arrow. The arrow points the way the force acts. A longer arrow is a bigger force. We write the size in newtons, N.
Often there are two forces in opposite directions. To see what happens, we add them up into one: the overall force.
Draw it first
Draw the forces on a pushed box
1 Draw the box. Draw the push as an arrow to the right. It is 25 N.
2 Friction pulls the other way. Draw a shorter arrow to the left. It is 10 N.
3 Take the small force from the big one. 25 − 10 = 15. The overall force is 15 N to the right.
When two forces act on a thing in opposite directions, the overall force is the difference between them. It points the way of the bigger force.
If the two forces are the same size, the overall force is zero. We say the forces are balanced. If they are not the same size, they are unbalanced.
The table pushes up with 20 N. Gravity pulls down with 20 N. The forces are balanced, so the bag does not move.
Balanced forces change nothing. A thing that is still stays still. A thing that is moving keeps moving at the same speed in the same direction.
The push and the friction are balanced. The box keeps its steady speed. It does not speed up and it does not slow down.
See it three ways
As a picture
In words
If the push is bigger, the overall force is forward and the box speeds up. If the two are equal, nothing changes. If friction is bigger, a box that is already sliding slows down.
In symbols
overall force = bigger force − smaller force. 25 − 10 = 15 N.
Worked example
A box is pushed to the right with 25 N. Friction pulls it to the left with 10 N. What is the overall force?
The forces point in opposite directions, so we take one from the other.
The bigger force is the push: 25 N to the right.
The smaller force is friction: 10 N to the left.
Overall force = 25 − 10 = 15 N.
The overall force points right, so the box speeds up to the right.
Answer: 15 N to the right
Try it
Pull a shoe at a steady speed
You need: an old shoe or a small box, a rubber band and a piece of string, a ruler, a smooth floor indoors.
Be safe: Pull on a clear floor. Keep your face away from the band in case it slips.
Tie the band to the shoe with the string. Hold the other end of the band.
Pull the shoe along the floor slowly. Try to keep it going at a steady speed.
Hold the ruler beside the band while you pull. Look at how long the band is.
Now pull harder so that the shoe speeds up. Watch the band.
Let go. Watch how the shoe slows down and stops.
What you will see: At a steady speed the band stays the same length. Your pull and the friction are balanced. When you pull harder the band gets longer and the shoe speeds up. When you let go, friction slows it down until it stops.
If you cannot try it, this is what happens.
A wrong idea many people have
A moving thing needs a force to keep it moving.
Why it feels right: In daily life things stop when we stop pushing them.
The test that breaks it: Slide a book across a table and let go. It stops quickly. Now put the book on three round pencils and push it the same way. It rolls much farther. The less friction, the farther it goes.
What is true: A moving thing keeps its speed and direction unless the forces on it are unbalanced. Friction and air resistance are the forces that slow things down.
Key words
overall force
all the forces on a thing added up into one.
balanced
two forces that are equal and opposite. The overall force is zero.
unbalanced
forces that are not equal. There is an overall force.
Back to your guess
The answer is A: The forces on it are balanced.
Two forces act on the bag. Gravity pulls it down and the table pushes it up. They are the same size, so they are balanced and the bag stays still.
Check yourself
Try each one before you look. A wrong answer tells you where to go next.
A box is pushed to the right with 45 N. Friction pulls it to the left with 15 N. What is the overall force?
See the answer
30 N to the right
The forces are opposite, so take one from the other. 45 − 15 = 30 N. The push is bigger, so the overall force points right.
Two children pull a rope from opposite ends. Kofi pulls with 60 N. Ana pulls with 45 N. What is the overall force on the rope?
See the answer
15 N towards Kofi
The pulls are opposite, so take one from the other. 60 − 45 = 15 N. Kofi pulls harder, so the rope moves towards Kofi.
If you chose A: You added the two pulls. They are in opposite directions, so they work against each other. Take one from the other. Go to S3.7.3.
If you chose B: The size is right, but the direction is not. The overall force points the way of the bigger pull, and Kofi pulls harder. Go to S3.7.3.
If you chose C: Zero is only for equal pulls. These two are different, so the rope moves towards the stronger one. Go to S3.7.3.
A bag of rice lies on a table. Its weight is 20 N down and the table pushes up with 20 N. What is the overall force on the bag?
See the answer
0 N. Nothing changes.
The forces are equal and opposite, so 20 − 20 = 0 N. The bag stays still.
If you chose A: You added the two forces. They point in opposite directions, so take one from the other. Go to S3.7.3.
If you chose C: The forces are equal. Neither one is bigger, so there is no overall force. Go to S3.7.3.
A skater glides on smooth ice in a straight line at a steady speed. What can you say about the forces on her?
See the answer
The forces on her are balanced.
Her speed and direction do not change, so the overall force is zero. The forces are balanced.
If you chose A: A moving thing does not need a force to keep it moving. This is the idea the wrong idea box talks about. Go to S3.7.3.
If you chose B: Gravity pulls her down and the ice pushes her up. They are balanced, not missing. Go to S2.5.1.
A box slides along the floor at a steady speed. The push is 10 N and the friction is 10 N. You keep pushing in the same way. What does the box do?
See the answer
It keeps the same speed in the same direction.
The push is 10 N and the friction is 10 N, so the overall force is 0 N. Balanced forces do not change speed or direction.
If you chose B: A push only speeds a box up when it is bigger than the friction. Here the two are equal. Go to S3.7.3.
If you chose C: Friction does pull back, but the push pulls forward just as hard. The overall force is zero, so the speed does not change. Go to S3.7.3.
A box slides to the right. You push it right with 12 N. Friction pulls it left with 20 N. What happens to the box?
See the answer
It slows down. The overall force is 8 N to the left.
The forces are opposite, so take one from the other. 20 − 12 = 8 N. Friction is bigger, so the overall force points left, against the movement, and the box slows down.
If you chose A: A push only speeds a box up when it is bigger than the friction. Here the friction is bigger. Go to S3.7.3.
If you chose B: Only balanced forces keep the speed the same. These two forces are not equal, so the speed changes. Go to S3.7.3.
If you chose C: Friction slows a moving thing and stops it. It does not make it turn round and go the other way. Go to S3.7.3.
From an earlier chapter
A walker's graph is flat from 40 s to 50 s. She is 40 m from home the whole time. What is her speed in these 10 seconds?
See the answer
0 m/s
On a distance and time graph a flat line means she is still. She moves 0 m in 10 s, so the speed is 0 ÷ 10 = 0 m/s.
If you chose A: You divided the distance from home by the time. Speed uses the distance she moved during those seconds. Go to S3.7.2.
If you chose C: That is the time. Find how far she moved in that time and divide. Go to S3.7.2.
Keep it
Copy this into your exercise book.
Forces in opposite directions: take one from the other. That is the overall force. Balanced forces give zero, so speed and direction do not change.
Draw: A box with a long arrow right, 25 N, and a short arrow left, 10 N. Write overall force 15 N.